Friday, May 29, 2009

Shame on you, Mr. Garcia

This morning one of my coworkers handed me the latest copy of eWeek. I flipped through it, and in horror I stumbled across "AV Fear and Loathing,"

"...over and over, I find that security suites are the buggiest, most troublesome applications on my systems. I’ve spent innumerable hours nursing these “solutions” along, working around them, fixing them, reinstalling them... I’m leaning toward forging ahead without AV again once Windows 7 comes out."

This is the most irresponsible IT article I've read for some time. Using security buzz words like "principle of least privilege," Mr. Garcia is suggesting that Windows 7 is so awesome that we will no longer need Anti-Virus. Apparently Mr. Garcia is unaware of the concept of implementing security in layers. Yes, Windows 7 runs in user mode with very few privileges. Undoubtedly, hackers will find a way around these security measures.

I will concede that the vast majority of consumer security suites out there are absolute shit. Mr. Garcia tried to use consumer versions of Panda, Trend Micro, Kaspersky, and BitDefender -- all software that I would never install on my computer. Instead of insisting all AV is junk, he should really look at some less intrusive solutions, like Avast! Home or Sophos (for the enterprise).

To conclude, the last thing we need is to tell people to not use Anti-Virus. A former supervisor told me long ago, using a computer without Anti-Virus is like having unprotected sex. In this analogy, running Windows 7 is like getting it on while using the Pill. Guess what might happen if you forget to take the Pill (Windows Updates) for a couple months? It's best to slap on a condom (Anti-Virus). It (er... your computing experience) may not feel as good, but it beats a zombie popping out of your NIC in 9 months.

No comments:

Post a Comment